*Written for the Holocaust Resource Center of Buffalo Writing Contest of 2009*
*The theme of this year's contest is: Paper is more patient than man.*
One characteristic of human beings is that we have a tendency to believe the things that we want to believe, and it may have been the reason that so many victims of the Holocaust chose to write down their thoughts and feelings, rather than telling someone else. This principle is illustrated early in Night, the memoir by Elie Wiesel. To start the memoir, Wiesel tells the story of Moshe the Beatle. Although the townspeople generally felt encumbered and embarrassed by the presence of the poor, Moshe was an exception; the citizens were fond of the man. When all foreign Jews were taken from the area, Moshe witnessed the horrid cruelty displayed by their captors. Escaping miraculously, and finding the strength to return to his town of Sighet only to tell his story as a warning to the others, he was ignored, even as a man that the people had formerly respected. “What an imagination he has,” or even, “Poor fellow, he’s gone mad,” were common phrases uttered by those who didn’t have the patience to listen and believe.
Paper, on the other hand, is an eternal, timeless listener, never stopping, never ignoring to whom it is listening. Anne Frank wrote in her diary, “And now I come to the root of the matter, the reason for my starting a diary: it is that I have no such real friend.” She did, in fact, have many people to whom she was close; she had friends, boyfriends, and her loving parents. Anne felt that some of the thoughts she needed to express would be better expressed to something with the tightest of lips, the best confident that hasn’t the slightest possibility of betraying trust. She would never have been able to tell anyone what she wrote on October 3rd, 1942, when she had acquired a, “terrible dislike,” for her mother. Anne also wrote on January 30, 1943, that she’s “seething with rage, yet I can’t show it,” because she, “couldn’t bear their sympathy or their good-humored derision.” Who would have had the patience to listen to her voice these feelings without passing judgment? Instead, she reached for her diary and wrote, “I want to write, but more than that, I want to bring out all kinds of things that lie buried deep in my heart.” Perhaps this is why Elie chose paper to reveal his unspeakable memories; he knows and teaches that, “You take a text, you explore it, you enter it with all your heart and all your mind… at one point, you understand something that you hadn’t understood before.”
The topic may be best described by the adapted words of Peter Brodie, who said that, “What lasts is what is written. We look to literature to find the essence of an age.” Brodie meant that because paper outlives man and has the ability to reach a wider audience, we can rely on literature from a given era to define that period of time. Especially in the scope of the Holocaust, we have learned of its shocking truth because of literature like Night and Anne Frank: The Diary of a Young Girl.
No comments:
Post a Comment